The results are in
On Sunday I acquired the Shattered Sun Pendant of Resolve. As I am Exalted with the Aldor, I was dubious about this necklace which on paper looks great as a threat piece. Would it stand the test in an environment where I want to build threat as fast as possible?
First off, I had to swap gear around. I usually use Shapeshifter’s Signet for the expertise in my threat set, but I needed to swap in a defense ring to be able to still be defense-capped while wearing the necklace. Not ideal.
The test environment was a Heroic Botanica run. I ran with two mages, a feral druid and a paladin. We used little CC (one sheep on all 3+ pulls, two sheep on the one 5-pull in the instance, druid as OT on the satyr pulls at Thorngrim). The run was pretty much flawless with zero wipes and the only deaths were when a Gene-Splicer ran loose long enough to cast Death&Decay on all ranged people. Hooray for battle rez.
Incidentally, said pull was where I threw the towel regarding the necklace. When you dread the sound of a proc, you know the item’s not right for you. Basically whenever I got a proc in the early stages of a pull, I would end up too rage-starved to easily multi-tank mobs. I did not even have the rage to Thunderclap. Mid-instance, I went back to wearing the Barbed Choker of Discipline plus the Shapeshifter’s Signet, and things improved threat-wise. I also did not really notice any big jumps in TPS output even when the necklace didn’t proc, so it was all rather disappointing.
I think I will pick up Shattered Sun Pendant of Might next and will give it a spin. It should work out a bit better, but I will miss the stamina. Strangely enough, I find the Aldor proc superior to the Scryers proc on this piece. Go figure. Why not try balancing the procs so both factions would be fine?

After wearing the SSO Pendant of Resolve for 3 months and then switching to the Booch of Deftness for the last 2 weeks I am noticing more threat. I think it is well worth the 35 badges.
Tankette’s last blog post..WoTLK anxiety, lifted somewhat
Reply